Tuesday, October 13, 2009

3 Pedal Force Simulator : Capturing The Outdoor Experience

Components of Pedal Force Simulator

Tom Compton, the personality behind AnalyticCycling.com, believes trainers do a shabby job of simulating outdoor riding conditions. There's that something missing in them.

Well, nothing new there, as most of us have felt the same since time immemorial. We all sit on these mechanisms and fool our brains into thinking we're doing the actual thing.

But what I like is that Compton expresses this "something missing" of trainers relevantly as follows. This collection of statements puts together an obvious problem in need of an engineered solution :

"Acceleration is the root cause of the difference (between actually riding outdoors on bicycles and indoors on trainers). Trainers model average power at constant speed and don't respond realistically to accelerations. So when you get up to sprint on a trainer, the pedal 'falls out from under you'. The acceleration of a trainer is wrong, wrong by as much as several orders of magnitude. After all, the mass of even a large-flywheel trainer is small compared to the mass of a rider."

Compton is now taking trainers one step forward with a cool add-on simulator that mimics real world riding conditions indoors.

How do you simulate real world conditions? It turns out that its all in the resistance force encountered at the pedals. Compton has designed a one package solution, called Pedal Force Simulator (PFS), through which riders can select a pre-programmed force simulator in a Palm device mounted on the handlebars. The simulation model is then communicated wireless to a computer at the rear wheel which then controls the pedaling resistance at about 1000 times per second.

The resistance computer of the PFS at the rear wheel

The PFS uses the standard validated model of forces acting on a rider to simulate instantaneous forces at the pedal. It measures acceleration and, using the standard model of forces acting on the rider and applies a resistive force at the pedals that is theoretically equal to the force a rider would feel riding outdoors under the simulated conditions (or theoretically sound). It does this using an eddy current brake that is electronically controlled by a computer in the resistance unit. The computer recalculates force at the pedals 1000 times per second so that the instantaneous force a rider feels at the pedal is always a theoretically correct force. [Source : Tom Compton]

Fig 2 : The display on the handlebars is a high-end Palm device with a large, color display area. Display software takes full advantage of the Palm device's capabilities. Displays and plots of parameters are provided. Workout data is saved to a sophisticated database. All measurement parameters normally expected are also provided. [Source]

The power of this system comes in customization and as said before, in mimicking outdoor variables. While there are pre-programmed courses in the simulator, a rider can also setup any ride profile he desires into the computer. Moreover, the PFS takes wind speed and direction as selected by the rider and transforms it in a way that gives realistic outdoor increases and decreases in wind speed which translates to a more realistic "windy" riding experience. As the wind is varied during the ride based on the model, the rider may feel necessary to shift into easier gears to pedal, just like in the real world.

After having built complete prototypes, all true and tested, Compton is now offering licensing of the technology.

In short, what is claimed by Compton is that the Pedal Force Simulator gets the instantaneous acceleration right. This affects the rider's ability to put power into the pedals and hence, captures real and subtle effects that one will never obtain on a trainer.

Thoughts and comments?

* * *


  1. Looks like he's using a Kurt Kinetic frame? Assuming I had the cash I would consider investing in something along these lines if he could rig it to a Kurt Rock and Roll. I have a Kurt Pro with the 18lb double flywheel which does a pretty good job. It seems like the one in the pictures would be limited more by the static upright position than the force on the pedals feel. You never hold a bike upright when out of the saddle.

    Doesn't the computrainer do this already? Or is it not doing the acceleration calculations? I'd imagine it could since the resistance is computer controlled.

  2. I noticed a Cyclocross setting... Do you have to dismount, lift the entire contraption, run in place, and remount?

  3. Phun : That is hilarious.


Thank you. I read every single comment.